do we think this is more impressive in CP than AP
What would be the AP equivalent to WP/CPS/CP, SAPD/LSQ/PB?
CP ABDs with Solo Hits in Top Subfield Journals
-
As someone who reviews for CPS a lot, including the entire tenure of Samuels and Ansell, they are smart enough to get the job but not smart enough to do it well. Appear to care about inference, but dont really understand it. Claim it's not just about China and Europe and Mexico, but run a tight RCT in Africa or MENA and they reject because "scope conditions." CPS doesn't publish good research at all.
-
As someone who reviews for CPS a lot, including the entire tenure of Samuels and Ansell, they are smart enough to get the job but not smart enough to do it well. Appear to care about inference, but dont really understand it. Claim it's not just about China and Europe and Mexico, but run a tight RCT in Africa or MENA and they reject because "scope conditions." CPS doesn't publish good research at all.
Are you sure the problem isn't the other reviewers? Many Africanists/MENA scholars are famously hostile towards RCT work.
-
WP is simultaneously quite interesting but unfortunately also quite clubby. Setting quality aside (which of course we shouldn't), I would be a bit skeptical about its value if the author is a current or recent Princeton student.
Also Princeton visitors and post-docs