^Grose (who poasts here)
Is USC a top 25 program?
-
USC has no junior stars but has not made any "horrible" hires either. It is a middling program that has a lot of average people and a few high-profile seniors who do place students.
Which seniors place at r1s?
PJ just placed student at purdue. another placed at howard.
-
Look at the record of the Howard placement…
USC has no junior stars but has not made any "horrible" hires either. It is a middling program that has a lot of average people and a few high-profile seniors who do place students.
Which seniors place at r1s?
PJ just placed student at purdue. another placed at howard. -
Top 10 from recent placements. KZ pulls it up to top 5. Hate all you want. USC is legit.
Imagine being so out to lunch that you think placing someone at W&M means anything.
For all the people naying this, you realize there are at least a dozen departments that place someone at a place better than W&M every single year right?
-
EBC's done well the past couple of years, no?
IDK anything about the others listed in that post, but ECB is doing interesting work and publishing it in good places. She's a solid hire for a program like USC. Very, very odd to characterize her as a "horrible" hire.In fairness, she published one piece in a fourth-tier journal in her first 4 years on the track, and during that time did odd things like put working papers in the "Peer-Reviewed Publications" section of her CV.
But she has broken through a bit, and will almost certainly be tenured.
-
USC has no junior stars but has not made any "horrible" hires either. It is a middling program that has a lot of average people and a few high-profile seniors who do place students.
Which seniors place at r1s?
PJ just placed student at purdue. another placed at howard.Ok 1. Any others?
-
AB (placed at Howard, AMH advisee) has no publications and no R&Rs and had multiple offers lol
USC has no junior stars but has not made any "horrible" hires either. It is a middling program that has a lot of average people and a few high-profile seniors who do place students.
Which seniors place at r1s?
PJ just placed student at purdue. another placed at howard.Ok 1. Any others?
-
While we're on it, what exactly is MB's qualification to get a job at Purdue? 3 publications in mid- or low-tier journals all coauthored with senior faculty? What a joke
AB (placed at Howard, AMH advisee) has no publications and no R&Rs and had multiple offers lol
USC has no junior stars but has not made any "horrible" hires either. It is a middling program that has a lot of average people and a few high-profile seniors who do place students.
Which seniors place at r1s?
PJ just placed student at purdue. another placed at howard.
Ok 1. Any others? -
USC has no junior stars but has not made any "horrible" hires either. It is a middling program that has a lot of average people and a few high-profile seniors who do place students.
Ehh. MP and PB are def on the rise.
Both leaving next year. BC/EBC might also be on their way out.
-
While we're on it, what exactly is MB's qualification to get a job at Purdue? 3 publications in mid- or low-tier journals all coauthored with senior faculty? What a joke
Perhaps the search committee read AB's work, and found it promising. Search committees still do that sometimes, you know. They don't all outsource substantive evaluation of the quality of research to anonymous peer reviewers.