Ellie
https://twitter.com/jaj7d/status/1098282044331765760
Well deserved smackdown
Jeane
The whole thread started by GG sounds ridiculous, including all the responses. It is the same as PSR, but lacking anonymity
Delta
But guys, GG is a feminist. How dare you slander him.
Olivette
1800-BLAUD's response was fair.
Suzette
That Penn dude looks like a reject for a Matt Whittaker impersonation.
Yo, bro. Why you go for that bald pinhead look, yo?
Feynman
Mess with the bull you get the horns
Lakisha
That is Ben Come Home for Dinner. Ben 1-800-Goodrich is a different Ben.
#knowyourPSRmemes
Kelly
You know that GG's number 1 reason he always gives for rejecting a paper (research note or otherwise) is the one he's complaining about now.
Forrest
JJ: What new reasonable theory are you referring to?
GG: Well, it involves...
JJ: IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT YOUR THEORY IS!!!!
Jacob
JJ's a cold mothaf^cka, but he's our cold mothaf^cka.
Harmon
I don't see what's wrong with the twitter thread. Yeah, GG shouldn't have started it, but JJ responses were reasonable.
Braden
The clowns who were liking his nonsense should start unliking. Weak.
Uland
I had a great experience with JJ as editor of my paper. He was tough but fair. I completely support his reply to GG's attack.
Topher
Now JJ trying to play it cool, like "oh yeah, THAT third review - well, now that you mention it, the outcome was cool and all..."
Never trust a self-described male feminist.
Lea
JJ's response was unnecessarily pissy. GG didn't need to go into as much detail as he did, but it is a fair point he is making about research notes.
Tianna
Mods have deleted a lot of posts on this thread defending Jenkins. Curious...
Rosanna
Omg political scientist need to get a life. “I just want to raise the issue of criteria for publishing research notes.” Now you go on twitter to whine if your “research note” does not get published.
Bertie
Twitter makes everyone look like an a**hole.
Winona
GG caught lying (or at least being highly deceptive). No mention of the third review until JJ calls him out.
JJ strong.