he is well-placed at Boise. He has made no substantive contributions to the discipline (and appears totally unhinged). Publishing a lot in Tier C journals is not a recipe for success beyond Boise. A few better pubs won't change that.
Ok RM.
Utych personally offended when other people do good research
-
He has a bunch of JOPs...
You mean a couple that he hit right out of grad school, of which he has not followed up on since?He literally just published in JOP within the last year.
Oh god guys, he has a JOP hit among his dozens of mediocre publications! Get this guy to Harvard!
-
He has a bunch of JOPs...
You mean a couple that he hit right out of grad school, of which he has not followed up on since?
He has a forthcoming CUP bookCoauthored with two other people.
Your thinking is either/or, Tami. Nobody's saying he should necessarily be at CHYMPS, but, at Boise State he is underplaced.
-
He keeps complaining about his ‘bad job’ yet from a holistic position, there’s nothing ‘bad’ about it considering the current state of academia.
If making $60k a year and living in a s**t location is considered "good" you have pretty low standards for your life imo.
-
He keeps complaining about his ‘bad job’ yet from a holistic position, there’s nothing ‘bad’ about it considering the current state of academia.
If making $60k a year and living in a s**t location is considered "good" you have pretty low standards for your life imo.Never been to Boise, I take it? It's one of the best cities in the US.
-
If he can't find a better job than Boise State having 5 JoPs and a handful of other decent pubs in his CV, the problem is the scholar and not the scholarship
Or maybe it's because his work is boring and incoherent and his personality is poisonous.
No one wants to hire him.
-
If he can't find a better job than Boise State having 5 JoPs and a handful of other decent pubs in his CV, the problem is the scholar and not the scholarship
Or maybe it's because his work is boring and incoherent and his personality is poisonous.
No one wants to hire him.How is his work "incoherent," Rahsaan? Because he has come up with more than one idea?
-
How is his work "incoherent," Rahsaan? Because he has come up with more than one idea?
So you are Steve then, give your defensiveness here? I'm not Rahsaan - the fact that you come on here to try and defend yourself is just another data point on your insecurity and pettiness.
Go get some help bro.
Because there's no coherent research agenda? It's mostly just a bunch of topics that don't really speak to one another pursued with coauthors?
-
How is his work "incoherent," Rahsaan? Because he has come up with more than one idea?
So you are Steve then, give your defensiveness here? I'm not Rahsaan - the fact that you come on here to try and defend yourself is just another data point on your insecurity and pettiness.
Go get some help bro.
Because there's no coherent research agenda? It's mostly just a bunch of topics that don't really speak to one another pursued with coauthors?Utych is toxic and nobody likes him but people not in his area want to work with him. Which is it?
-
talk about a guy who punches above his weight. Found a nice racket (immigration, comparative), has the right demo characteristics, and found himself at Duke.
More power to him, he played the game right. But a great intellect this man isn't.
Dude went to full on the weight of 2 CPS and 1 APSR while associate, and a handful of articles in journals of no repute.Strong mischaracterization of his record. How about two books (1 Cambridge), 2 CPS, a solo APSR, a solo BJPS plus lots of filler.
Love how CPS is considered a great journal for RM but Political Behavior is a third tier journal for SU.
Both journals have similar 5 year impact factors and are both great journals.